10 Common Misconceptions Consumers Have About Roofers
1. “Roofers Are Just Laborers”
Example: “I mean, how hard can it be? It’s just nailing some shingles, right?” – Homeowner on a consultation call
Reality: Roofing is a highly skilled profession that blends manual labor with complex technical expertise. Beyond simply “nailing shingles,” roofers are responsible for load calculations, understanding material science, and executing waterproofing strategies that prevent structural rot and mold. Professional roofers interpret blueprints, use specialized tools, and meet strict building codes. OSHA training, continuing education, and manufacturer certifications (like GAF Master Elite) are common among reputable contractors. A poor roofing job can cause long-term water damage, reduce energy efficiency, and lower property value.
2. “All Roofers Are the Same”
Example: “They’re all using the same shingles—why not just pick the cheapest guy?” – Budget-focused homeowner
Reality: The quality of roofing work depends heavily on the installer, not just the materials. Two contractors using identical shingles can yield drastically different outcomes depending on their training, attention to detail, and adherence to best practices. Higher-end roofers may offer better installation warranties, use enhanced underlayment systems, and employ in-house teams instead of subcontractors. The National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA) emphasizes that labor is the #1 factor in roof longevity. Choosing based on price alone may cost more in repairs and early replacement.
3. “Roofers Overcharge for Materials”
Example: “I found shingles at the hardware store for $80 a square. Why are they quoting me $150?”
Reality: A roofing quote covers far more than shingles. Professional roofers include costs for delivery, tear-off of old materials, underlayment, ice and water barriers, flashing, vent boots, fasteners, safety gear, warranties, and labor. Additionally, contractors factor in equipment use (such as dump trailers, cranes, or lifts), overhead, and insurance premiums. Home improvement chains may sell discounted shingles, but they rarely include the systems that make a roof functional and watertight.
4. “Roofing Doesn’t Require Permits or Inspections”
Example: “My buddy just got his roof done in a weekend—no permit needed.”
Reality: Most municipalities require roofing permits to ensure the work complies with building codes. This includes proper nailing patterns, fire safety standards, and ventilation requirements. Failure to pull a permit can result in fines, forced tear-offs, or denial of future home insurance claims. Licensed contractors follow protocols to protect both the homeowner and themselves. Roofing inspections also protect you from fly-by-night companies doing subpar work that goes unnoticed until it fails.
5. “Anyone Can Be a Roofer”
Example: “My cousin’s pretty handy—he can probably do the roof for half the cost.”
Reality: Roofing is one of the most dangerous jobs in construction, requiring rigorous safety training and physical stamina. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, roofers face a high risk of injury from falls, heat, and sharp tools. Professional roofers are OSHA-certified, trained to work at height with fall protection systems, and understand complex systems like attic ventilation and thermal insulation. Improper installations can lead to insurance claim denials or voided warranties. Licensed roofers also know how to handle flashing, valleys, and other water-sensitive areas that are critical to long-term performance.
6. “Insurance Covers Everything”
Example: “The storm hit last week—my insurance will pay for the whole roof, no problem.”
Reality: Insurance typically covers only damage caused by specific perils, such as hail or wind, and not for aging or neglect. Adjusters inspect for prior wear, maintenance neglect, or pre-existing conditions, and may deny full coverage. Without accurate documentation and experienced contractor input, homeowners often receive reduced settlements. Some policies even depreciate the roof value based on age. Hiring a contractor experienced in insurance claims can make the difference between full and partial coverage.
7. “Metal Roofs Are Too Loud”
Example: “I grew up in a barn. I remember rain hitting the metal roof—it sounded like a freight train.”
Reality: Modern metal roofs are nothing like bare barn tin. Today’s systems include underlayment, solid sheathing, attic insulation, and often sound-deadening barriers. A study by the Metal Roofing Alliance found that decibel levels in homes with metal roofs were comparable to those with asphalt when properly installed. The noise issue is usually a result of improper installation or lack of insulation—not the metal itself.
8. “Roofing Work Can Be Done in Any Weather”
Example: “You said you’d start this week—why does a little drizzle delay everything?”
Reality: Roofing materials rely on dry conditions to seal properly. Self-adhering membranes and asphalt shingles require specific temperatures to bond. Installing during wet or freezing weather can compromise the integrity of the system. Many manufacturers void warranties if installation occurs in unsuitable weather. Beyond quality, safety is also at risk: slick surfaces increase the likelihood of slips and falls. Responsible roofers delay for good reason.
9. “You Don’t Need to Maintain a Roof”
Example: “I thought a 30-year shingle meant I didn’t have to touch it for 30 years.”
Reality: A “30-year” rating is based on ideal lab conditions, not real-world weather, UV exposure, and debris buildup. Roofs need annual or biannual inspections to check for cracked caulking, loose flashing, clogged gutters, and moss or algae growth. Without these, even high-end shingles can fail in half their rated lifespan. Think of roofing like your car—it needs maintenance to meet its full service life.
10. “Roofers Just Want to Sell You a New Roof”
Example: “They’re probably going to tell me it’s totaled—even if it’s a minor leak.”
Reality: Ethical roofers prioritize long-term relationships and reputation over upselling. Many reputable contractors offer repair services and document the specific areas needing attention. Drones, thermal imaging, and photo documentation give homeowners visual proof of issues. National surveys show that homeowners who use certified roofing companies are more likely to receive repair options before replacement is discussed.
